Placeholder canvas
Date: January 9, 2018

Client Alert: Washington State Asbestos Update 1/9/2018 Noll v. American Biltrite Inc. Remand: 188 Wash.2d 402, 395 P.3d 1021 (January 8, 2017) Trial Court Order: December 15, 2017

by foleyandmansfield
Date: January 9, 2018
by foleyandmansfield

Client Alert: Washington State Asbestos Update 1/9/2018 Noll v. American Biltrite Inc. Remand: 188 Wash.2d 402, 395 P.3d 1021 (January 8, 2017) Trial Court Order: December 15, 2017

Placeholder canvas

SUMMARY

On remand by the Washington Supreme Court, trial court denied plaintiff’s motion to establish personal jurisdiction over out-of-state supplier of asbestos used as component of asbestos-cement pipe.

FACTS

Plaintiff developed mesothelioma after exposure to a variety of asbestos-containing products throughout a lifetime of work, including a cement pipe manufactured by a California company named Certain-Teed, using asbestos supplied by a Wisconsin company named Special Electric. During the key period, Certain-Teed sold and shipped a substantial amount of its pipe into Washington.

Plaintiff alleged that Washington courts could exercise specific personal jurisdiction over Special Electric purely because it had sent a harmful product into the stream of commerce where it was incorporated by Certain-Teed into a finished product that made its way into Washington where it allegedly injured plaintiff. 

The Washington Supreme Court reaffirmed the position it adopted in State v. LG Electronics, Inc., 186 Wn.2d 169, 375 P.3d 1035 (2016) that, based on Justice Breyer’s concurrence in J. McIntyre Mach., Ltd. v. Nicastro, 564 U.S. 873, 131 S. Ct. 2780, 180 L. Ed. 2d 765 (2011), a prima facie case for specific personal jurisdiction over a component manufacturer is satisfied where the complaint alleges that the defendant sold its product into the stream of commerce with the intent that the product would come into Washington.

The majority concluded that the intent allegation was missing in Noll. This was important, according to the majority, because recent U.S. Supreme Court precedent involving specific jurisdiction has “reaffirmed that the relevant relationship between a defendant and a forum must arise out of the contacts that the defendant itself creates with the forum state.” Noll at 414-15, (citing Walden v. Fiore, 134 S. Ct. 1115, 188 L. Ed. 2d 12 (2014)) (underscoring added).

The Washington Supreme Court decided that the plaintiff failed to allege sufficient facts for Washington courts to exercise specific personal jurisdiction over Special Electric under the stream of commerce doctrine, and remanded the case to the trial court for further consideration in light of LG Electronics.

HOLDING

On remand, the trial court held that evidence presented by plaintiff was insufficient to establish that Special Electric purposefully availed itself of the benefit and protections of the Washington marketplace.

SIGNIFICANCE

Merely alleging that an out-of-state component supplier sold a part to another out-of-state manufacturer which then sold the finished product in Washington will not satisfy the requirements of due process, even if there is evidence of a close working relationship between the supplier and manufacturer.

 

For additional information, please contact:

James D. Hicks at 206-456-5068 or jhicks@foleymansfield.com

 

Foley & Mansfield Logo

Ebony S. Morris Selected as a Nominee for the Louisiana Association of Defense Counsel’s 2023 Frank L. Maraist Award

Foley Mansfield is thrilled to announce at Ebony S. Morris, Attorney in the firm’s New Orleans office, has been nominated for the Louisiana Association of Defense Counsel’s (LADC) Frank L. Maraist Award. The Award, established by the LADC’s Young Lawyers Committee in 2015, is named for Professor Maraist, the first […]

LEARN MORE

Foley Mansfield Ranked in 2024 Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms” List

Foley Mansfield is pleased to announce that the firm has been ranked in two regions and practice areas in the 2024 Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms” List, one of the most trusted nationwide classifications available for law firms. Firms on the list are identified for their professional excellence, earning consistently […]

LEARN MORE

Foley Mansfield Recognized by Leadership Council on Legal Diversity as 2023 Compass Award Winner

Foley Mansfield is pleased to announce that the firm is a recipient of the Leadership Council on Legal Diversity’s (LCLD) 2023 Compass Award. This marks the firm’s second year achieving this designation, which recognizes those law firms and corporations demonstrating a strong, continuous commitment to building more diverse organizations and […]

LEARN MORE