Placeholder canvas
Date: December 9, 2016

Client Alert: Mistrial in Minnesota Asbestos Case Eileen and Delvin Domagala v. 3M Company, et al.

by foleyandmansfield
Date: December 9, 2016
by foleyandmansfield

Client Alert: Mistrial in Minnesota Asbestos Case Eileen and Delvin Domagala v. 3M Company, et al.

Placeholder canvas

Trial began on Monday, December 5 in the case of Eileen and Delvin Domagala v. 3M Company, et al., in St. Paul, Ramsey County, Minnesota, Before the Honorable John Guthmann.  Plaintiffs were represented by Jessica Dean of Dean, Omar, & Branham, LLP.  The three remaining Defendants in the case were Georgia Pacific, CertainTeed, and John Crane. 

Opening statements began this morning, December 8.  During her opening statement, Ms. Dean made multiple statements in violation of several of Judge Guthmann’s orders on both parties’ Motions in Limine.  The judge sustained several defense objections, and allowed Ms. Dean to finish her opening statement.  Following a recess, the Judge heard motions for mistrial from all three defendants.  After considering all arguments, the Judge ruled that Ms. Dean’s statements were so prejudicial that he had no choice but to grant a mistrial in favor of all three Defendants.  

Jury selection for the new trial is set to begin Monday, December 12, 2016, at 9:00 A.M.  

 

Please contact attorney Elena Rozwadowski at 612.216.0213 or erozwadowski@foleymansfield.com for questions or further information.

 

Foley & Mansfield Logo

Amended FRE 702 Creates Path for Expert Challenges in Talc Litigation

A recent update to the federal rules governing the use of expert testimony/evidence in federal court will widely impact how scientific and medical evidence is presented to juries in federal matters, including talcum powder litigation. With the change to Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence (“FRE 702”), defendants […]

LEARN MORE

Summarizing “ILR Briefly: The Asbestos Over-Naming and Trust Transparency Problem: A Philadelphia Case Study”

Introduction Asbestos litigation has become a cornerstone of the American legal landscape, spanning over four decades, and involving more than a million individual personal injury claims across state and federal courts. In 2012, a commentary titled “The Philadelphia Story: Asbestos Litigation, Bankruptcy Trusts, and Changes in Exposure Allegations from 1991-2010” […]

LEARN MORE

Minnesota Legislature Seeks to Change Newly Effective Earned Safe and Sick Time Law

By now, employers should be familiar with and implementing (if applicable) Minnesota’s Earned Safe and Sick Time law (“ESST”) that took effect on January 1, 2024. ESST is paid leave that an employee may use when they or a family member are sick, need to see a doctor or medical […]

LEARN MORE