> Insights > Client Alert: Missouri Joins Majority of Courts in Adopting Daubert Standard for Admissibility of Expert Witness Testimony

> Insights > Client Alert: Missouri Joins Majority of Courts in Adopting Daubert Standard for Admissibility of Expert Witness Testimony

Client Alert: Missouri Joins Majority of Courts in Adopting Daubert Standard for Admissibility of Expert Witness Testimony

April 3, 2017Client Alerts

Last week, Missouri joined the United States federal courts, as well as the majority of other state courts, in adopting a heightened standard for the admissibility of expert opinions commonly known as the “Daubert standard.”  The Daubert standard comes from the landmark Supreme Court case of Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993), and is generally considered to increase the reliability of expert witness testimony by requiring the trial court serve as the gatekeeper of evidence and opinions provided by expert witnesses.

Aligning with Daubert, the new Missouri standard requires that in order for an expert to testify, the Court must find (1) The expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue; (b) The testimony is based on sufficient facts or data; (c) The testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and, (d) The expert has reliably applied the principles and methods to the facts of the case.  § 490.065, RSMo (2017). The first element of the test is nothing new for Missouri cases.  The other three, analyzed together, are what could create a change in the type, and quality, of lawsuits permitted to proceed in Missouri.

Under the old standard, which had been the law in Missouri since before the Supreme Court issued the Daubert opinion, “the facts or data in a particular case… must be of a type reasonably relied upon by experts in the field in forming opinions or inferences upon the subject and must be otherwise reasonably reliable.” § 490.065, RSMo (amended 2017).  Expert testimony provided under this standard was sometimes criticized and argued to be “junk science.”  Supporters of the change, who are often businesses that feel  unfairly targeted by lawsuits , argued the now-repealed Missouri rule had been setting the bar too low and allowing questionable cases to proceed with the support of dubious expert opinions. Those opposed to the new heightened standard, often the plaintiffs who carry the burden of proof in a case, argue a change will merely cause undue delay and increase court costs.  

By repealing the older version of Section 490.065, Missouri Governor Eric Greitens hoped to improve the state’s civil justice system and business climate through tort reform.  For the first time in eight years, Republicans control both the executive and legislative branch, and it is expected that they will put forth many other changes and initiatives with the same objectives.  Whether the new standard for the admissibility of expert witness testimony will make a measurable impact is yet to be seen.  Neighboring Illinois, parts of which are haunted by a similar reputation as “judicial hellholes,” has yet to adopt Daubert.  Instead, it utilizes the Frye test, which only requires that the scientific technique on which an opinion is based  be generally accepted as reliable in the relevant scientific community. Frye v. United States, 293 F. 1013 (D.C. Cir. 1923); ll. R. Evid. 702.

 

For more information, contact Mandy Williams in Foley & Mansfield’s St. Louis office at 314.925.5701 or mwilliams@foleymansfield.com.

 

Mandy Williams

Related Practice Areas & Industries

View All Practice Areas & Industries

Related Locations

View All Locations

Related Professionals

View All Professionals

Recent News & Insights

  • Foley Mansfield Recognized by LCLD as a 2026 Top Performer and Compass Award Recipient

    Foley Mansfield is pleased to announce that the firm has been named a Top Performer and Compass Award winner by the Leadership Council on Legal Diversity, which recognizes...

  • Foley Mansfield Recognized by Best Law Firms 2027

    Foley Mansfield is proud to announce the firm’s inclusion in Best Law Firms 2027. The Best Law Firms methodology combines multiple data sources to assess law firm performance,...

  • Dennis Vega and Joseph Angiolillo Named to 2026 New York Metro Super Lawyers List

    Foley Mansfield is proud to announce that two Partners in our New York office have been named to the 2026 New York Metro Super Lawyers list. Dennis Vega,...

  • Foley Mansfield Continues Strategic Growth with Seven Additional Attorneys Q3

    Foley Mansfield continued its strategic growth during the third quarter, welcoming seven attorneys across its Chicago, Kansas City, Los Angeles, St. Louis and Walnut Creek offices. Joining the...